• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • About Us
  • Contact
  • Advertising
  • Join PGM
Pepperdine Graphic

Pepperdine Graphic

  • News
    • Good News
  • Sports
    • Hot Shots
  • Life & Arts
  • Perspectives
    • Advice Column
    • Waves Comic
  • GNews
    • Staff Spotlights
    • First and Foremost
    • Allgood Food
    • Pepp in Your Step
    • DunnCensored
    • Beyond the Statistics
  • Special Publications
    • 5 Years In
    • L.A. County Fires
    • Change in Sports
    • Solutions Journalism: Climate Anxiety
    • Common Threads
    • Art Edition
    • Peace Through Music
    • Climate Change
    • Everybody Has One
    • If It Bleeds
    • By the Numbers
    • LGBTQ+ Edition: We Are All Human
    • Where We Stand: One Year Later
    • In the Midst of Tragedy
  • Currents
    • Currents Spring 2025
    • Currents Fall 2024
    • Currents Spring 2024
    • Currents Winter 2024
    • Currents Spring 2023
    • Currents Fall 2022
    • Spring 2022: Moments
    • Fall 2021: Global Citizenship
    • Spring 2021: Beauty From Ashes
    • Fall 2020: Humans of Pepperdine
    • Spring 2020: Everyday Feminism
    • Fall 2019: Challenging Perceptions of Light & Dark
  • Podcasts
    • On the Other Hand
    • RE: Connect
    • Small Studio Sessions
    • SportsWaves
    • The Graph
    • The Melanated Muckraker
  • Print Editions
  • NewsWaves
  • Sponsored Content
  • Digital Deliveries
  • DPS Crime Logs

Staff Editorial: Opinionated Journalism is Unethical Journalism

February 18, 2020 by Graphic Staff

Art by Madeline Duvall

Last week’s news story about Kenneth Starr received criticism in the days following its publishing. “Hey Pepperdine Graphic, this is not someone you want to promote as associated with the university,” commented Facebook user Darin Campbell. Another user, Den Herring mirrored Campbell’s sentiment: “Is this an appropriate flex?”

These comments reflect a common misconception about the media: that when we report on a given topic, we are offering judgment, or in some cases, sponsorship and promotion. However, the Graphic’s entire journalistic process is crafted to do exactly the opposite.

We intended for our coverage of Starr’s appointment to Trump’s defense counsel to serve as a snapshot into his time at Pepperdine. Unlike some readers may have expected, it was not supposed to serve as a lambasting of Starr’s resumé in legal affairs throughout the decades.

At the Graphic, when we choose stories, we always start by asking ourselves, “What can we, as a college newspaper dedicated to covering Pepperdine and Malibu news, add to the story that’s not already out there?” A quick Google search of Starr’s name will provide one with an exhaustive history of his career. Whether he deserves it or not, it would be irresponsible of us to add another drop into the overflowing bucket of Starr smear-pieces on the internet.

At the same time, we try to take an objective approach when covering a story, which is common practice in journalism. Although some of the stories we choose to cover contain controversial topics or individuals, that doesn’t mean we support or endorse them. By trying to uphold an unbiased approach in covering any new story, we uphold certain ethical standards that every journalist is expected to abide by.

If our online compatriots took the time to read the piece, they would find a few quotes referencing the controversial nature of Starr’s career. We were not reluctant to include criticisms of Starr; in fact, our reporters asked all of their sources for comment about Starr’s contentious history. Those questions yielded no significant answers, and thus many were not included in the story. If our reporters were to merely comment on Starr’s past using buzzwords like ‘controversial’ or ‘scandalous,’ they would be blending the line between editorial writing and journalism, which threatens the integrity of our paper.

When you read a Graphic article, please know that a great deal of thought and care has gone on behind the scenes, and we always try to take an objective approach with the stories we cover. While some stories might contain content that you don’t necessarily agree with, that doesn’t mean it isn’t important to cover. When you expect judgment or bias from a news story, that would require opinion rather than fact. Which would you rather have?

____________________________________

Follow the Pepperdine Graphic on Twitter: @PeppGraphic

Filed Under: Featured, Perspectives Tagged With: commentary, Ethics, Facebook, journalism, journalism ethics, Kenneth Starr, Reporters, reporting, Staff Ed, Staff Editorial, Trump

Primary Sidebar

Categories

  • Featured
  • News
  • Life & Arts
  • Perspectives
  • Sports
  • Podcasts
  • G News
  • COVID-19
  • Fall 2021: Global Citizenship
  • Everybody Has One
  • Newsletters

Footer

Pepperdine Graphic Media
Copyright © 2025 · Pepperdine Graphic

Contact Us

Advertising
(310) 506-4318
peppgraphicadvertising@gmail.com

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
(310) 506-4311
peppgraphicmedia@gmail.com
Student Publications
Pepperdine University
24255 Pacific Coast Hwy
Malibu, CA 90263
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • YouTube